Worth reading on line at ‘Bound Together’ or in full below. President Obama's Tucscon speech:
President Obama and Sarah Palin Embrace a Nation
Editorial of The New York Sun January 12, 2011
President Obama spoke beautifully at Tucson this evening in a much-needed speech. It is hard to imagine how his remarks could have been improved. No doubt there will be some less generous in their appraisal, but that is our reaction. We haven’t heard such a performance from the president since his “one America” speech at the Democratic National Convention in 2004. At Tucson the president capped a week of shock, grief, and anger by reaching for the best in all of us and bidding America to recapture the wonder and the dream of a nine-year-old girl who had gone to hear her congresswoman.
One of the remarkable things that came through in the broadcasts we watched of the event was the way a whole nation turned to embrace what is, in Tucson, a relatively small, university town. The congresswoman, the judge, the student hero, the university president, and Republican governor, the former Democratic governor, the Mexican-American physician with Indian ancestry, they all, among others, know each other in the intimacy of a small town. Yet they represent themes that reach out to our whole vast country in an inspiring way.
The most surprising, and admirable, element of the Mr. Obama’s speech, was the pointedness with which he rejected the accusations against Sarah Palin and her colleagues in the Tea Party movement to whom the left wing of the president’s own party has been trying so shamelessly these past few days to attach the blame. Mr. Obama welcomed a wide debate on all the issues, but he made no plea for gun control, no call for regulations on political speech, nor bid for censorship of the images our politicians use in targeting their opponents. He may join in that; we shall see. This evening, he had a different message.
“At a time when our discourse has become so sharply polarized — at a time when we are far too eager to lay the blame for all that ails the world at the feet of those who think differently than we do — it's important for us to pause for a moment and make sure that we are talking with each other in a way that heals, not a way that wounds,” he said in a none-too-subtle rejection of the Paul Krugman, New York Times line that has emerged in the wake of the shootings. “[W]hat we can't do is use this tragedy as one more occasion to turn on one another.”
The president’s remarks were consonant with the statement earlier in the day by Sarah Palin, who has borne the brunt of the left-wing attacks with such admirable restraint since the New York Times and others began tuning up against her without so much as a quark of evidence that any of her rousing political rhetoric these past two years had anything to do with the killer’s motivations. The president’s point was Mrs. Palin’s point when she warned that journalists and pundits “should not manufacture a blood libel that serves only to incite the very hatred and violence they purport to condemn.”
Mrs. Palin, by speaking up for herself when so many turned on her, was speaking up for the rights of all Americans to participate vigorously in our national debate — and she was marking the same point the president made, when he called on each of us to enter the fray with “a good dose of humility.” We liked the way he put it when he said: “Rather than pointing fingers or assigning blame, let us use this occasion to expand our moral imaginations, to listen to each other more carefully, to sharpen our instincts for empathy, and remind ourselves of all the ways our hopes and dreams are bound together.”
Thursday, January 13, 2011
Israelis rush to Tel Aviv
We in the States think we know traffic. Let me tell you, the people in Israel know traffic, too. Traffic jams getting to and out of Israel's major cities have increased greatly in the past 10 years. A country whose citizens could not embrace the automobile for 50 years because of the price of cars and fuel, now finds itself jammed with them.
So, no surprise that Israel, a technologically advanced country, is thinking outside the box when it comes to its highways and alleviating traffic flow problems. Privately owned toll roads are now being planned for a Tel Aviv highway that will charge drivers for when they drive.
Here's the report: Tel Aviv fast lane is a world first - Globes.
Be sure, if it works, look for similar thinking to occur in the United States.
So, no surprise that Israel, a technologically advanced country, is thinking outside the box when it comes to its highways and alleviating traffic flow problems. Privately owned toll roads are now being planned for a Tel Aviv highway that will charge drivers for when they drive.
Here's the report: Tel Aviv fast lane is a world first - Globes.
Be sure, if it works, look for similar thinking to occur in the United States.
Friday, December 31, 2010
Rabbi Nasanyl Braun – corporeality and action/thought
This sermon by Rabbi Nasanyl Braun of Congregation Brothers of Israel in Elberon, New Jersey was presented in 2007. It addresses questions raised in the Torah portion read this week in synagogues around the world.
Early this week my son Avi came to me with an interesting question. Why don’t you tell Ima what to do? I responded that I did not think it was a good idea but I began to wonder where the question was coming from. So I asked him- “Avi why did you ask me that question?” His response was equally fascinating. He had just learned the story of Adam and Eve, Adam and Chava, in school and after they are banished from the Garden of Eden they are punished as well.
Genesis, Chapter 3:
You see said Avi, you should tell Ima what to do. Then he stopped, thought and said, “you know that Savta always tells grandpa what to do. Why is that?”
I ended the conversation by telling him that was not exactly what the Torah meant.
Of course his question is a really good question- the Torah says that “he will rule over you!” Taken literally it raises two important questions:
1. Is this an idea that fits within our worldview?
2. This was Avi’s question- the Torah’s promise does not seem to fit with our reality and experience. This punishment does not seem to be occurring.
This conversation captured one of the great difficulties faced in writing, teaching and understanding the Torah. It is a book read and learned by both eight year old children and aged scholars and it needs to be understood by both of them. Our Torah is a book of great depth and profound truth yet one that needs to be generally accessible and applicable to all people; even those who cannot yet comprehend the deeper ideas contained within in and do not yet have the ability to understand its many levels of interpretation. This at times leads to confusion and complications and even wrong ideas but it could be no other way.
Maybe the most famous example of this phenomenon can be found in today’s Torah reading.
Take the following two verses from our parsha:
Chapter 6:
Chapter 7:
Taken literally this would imply that God has a body. We now know this to be not true. Yet that was not always the case. The responsa of the rishonim testify to a perception amongst some that God did have a body. The Raavad in his famous critique of the Rambam’s position that labels anyone who believes that God has a body a heretic, writes the following: “they are mistaken and not heretics”. Raavad then adds-“ people better and greater than you (i.e. the Rambam) have entertained such a belief.” We even have manuscript evidence of a Tosafist who believed that God was corporeal.
This past week I spent a fair amount of time unpacking boxes that had been in storage for the last 2 & ½ years. There was one box that I knew was there that had a number of books that I really liked and missed. I am still angry at the movers for misplacing it. In addition to those I had small volume, a manuscript from Rabi Moshe Taku, a French Tosafist from the 13th century who claimed that God had a body!
Where does this mistaken belief come from? It emanates from the text itself- “the arm and hand that are outstretched.” These are some of the verses used to support Rabbi Taku’s position.
To properly understand the text you would need to know two things:
1. Why can’t God have a body?
2. If that is indeed what we believe, than why does the torah use this language?
I am not interested in the answer to the first question right now, although it is not as simple as one might think. As to the second question, why does the torah then use this terminolog?
There is a general consensus that the Torah needs to be written in a way that everyone can understand and relate to. The rabbis captured this idea with the phrase “dibra torah kilshon bnai adam” –the Torah speaks in the language of man.” The Torah uses language that can be easily understood even though it is not 100% accurate.
Yes, it can be confusing and difficult, but the upside is that the Torah provides you with an opportunity for continued learning and challenges.
I will admit to schepping real nachas after my conversation with Avi as I began to see him trying to apply the Torah’s text and come to an understanding of them that matches his reality.
Each of us should face that challenge, no matter our level of knowledge at the moment.
As you grow and learn, new and deeper meanings reveal themselves to you and that is part of the fun of Torah study. If it is not fun, God forbid, then you simply have not been doing it right!
##
Early this week my son Avi came to me with an interesting question. Why don’t you tell Ima what to do? I responded that I did not think it was a good idea but I began to wonder where the question was coming from. So I asked him- “Avi why did you ask me that question?” His response was equally fascinating. He had just learned the story of Adam and Eve, Adam and Chava, in school and after they are banished from the Garden of Eden they are punished as well.
Genesis, Chapter 3:
16. To the woman he said, I will greatly multiply the pain of your child bearing; in sorrow you shall bring forth children; and your desire shall be to your husband, and he shall rule over you.
You see said Avi, you should tell Ima what to do. Then he stopped, thought and said, “you know that Savta always tells grandpa what to do. Why is that?”
I ended the conversation by telling him that was not exactly what the Torah meant.
Of course his question is a really good question- the Torah says that “he will rule over you!” Taken literally it raises two important questions:
1. Is this an idea that fits within our worldview?
2. This was Avi’s question- the Torah’s promise does not seem to fit with our reality and experience. This punishment does not seem to be occurring.
This conversation captured one of the great difficulties faced in writing, teaching and understanding the Torah. It is a book read and learned by both eight year old children and aged scholars and it needs to be understood by both of them. Our Torah is a book of great depth and profound truth yet one that needs to be generally accessible and applicable to all people; even those who cannot yet comprehend the deeper ideas contained within in and do not yet have the ability to understand its many levels of interpretation. This at times leads to confusion and complications and even wrong ideas but it could be no other way.
Maybe the most famous example of this phenomenon can be found in today’s Torah reading.
Take the following two verses from our parsha:
Chapter 6:
6. Therefore say to the people of Israel, I am the Lord, and I will bring you out from under the burdens of the Egyptians, and I will rid you from their slavery, and I will redeem you with an outstretched arm, and with great judgments;
Chapter 7:
5. And the Egyptians shall know that I am the Lord, when I stretch forth my hand upon Egypt, and bring out the people of Israel from among them.
Taken literally this would imply that God has a body. We now know this to be not true. Yet that was not always the case. The responsa of the rishonim testify to a perception amongst some that God did have a body. The Raavad in his famous critique of the Rambam’s position that labels anyone who believes that God has a body a heretic, writes the following: “they are mistaken and not heretics”. Raavad then adds-“ people better and greater than you (i.e. the Rambam) have entertained such a belief.” We even have manuscript evidence of a Tosafist who believed that God was corporeal.
This past week I spent a fair amount of time unpacking boxes that had been in storage for the last 2 & ½ years. There was one box that I knew was there that had a number of books that I really liked and missed. I am still angry at the movers for misplacing it. In addition to those I had small volume, a manuscript from Rabi Moshe Taku, a French Tosafist from the 13th century who claimed that God had a body!
Where does this mistaken belief come from? It emanates from the text itself- “the arm and hand that are outstretched.” These are some of the verses used to support Rabbi Taku’s position.
To properly understand the text you would need to know two things:
1. Why can’t God have a body?
2. If that is indeed what we believe, than why does the torah use this language?
I am not interested in the answer to the first question right now, although it is not as simple as one might think. As to the second question, why does the torah then use this terminolog?
There is a general consensus that the Torah needs to be written in a way that everyone can understand and relate to. The rabbis captured this idea with the phrase “dibra torah kilshon bnai adam” –the Torah speaks in the language of man.” The Torah uses language that can be easily understood even though it is not 100% accurate.
Yes, it can be confusing and difficult, but the upside is that the Torah provides you with an opportunity for continued learning and challenges.
I will admit to schepping real nachas after my conversation with Avi as I began to see him trying to apply the Torah’s text and come to an understanding of them that matches his reality.
Each of us should face that challenge, no matter our level of knowledge at the moment.
As you grow and learn, new and deeper meanings reveal themselves to you and that is part of the fun of Torah study. If it is not fun, God forbid, then you simply have not been doing it right!
##
Thursday, December 30, 2010
Defensible borders for Israel
Isi Liebler writing on Jpost.com says,
Read, Candidly Speaking: Unite on defensible borders and see what you think about Liebler's suggestions.
Well, that's what I have to say. Stephen M. Flatow
There may indeed be differences over the determination of final borders and some settlements. But Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu, Kadima leader Tzipi Livni, Avigdor Lieberman of Israel Beiteinu and Ehud Barak of Labor surely all recognize that it is crucial to retain defensible borders and the major settlement blocs. They surely also concur that prior to making further concessions, there must be a clear formula to ensure that a future Palestinian state will be demilitarized, and would not merely become a platform from which Iran can launch new attacks. There should be affirmation by all mainstream parties to stand firm on these issues.There's the rub-- neither Livni, Lieberman nor Barak can keep their destabilizing comments to themselves. Only in Israel can a prime minister have a government where his partners speak against his policies. Time for an election system change in Israel.
Read, Candidly Speaking: Unite on defensible borders and see what you think about Liebler's suggestions.
Well, that's what I have to say. Stephen M. Flatow
Labels:
borders,
Israel,
jpost.com,
Palestinians
Another Madoff investor in trustee's sights?
From of all places, a "yeshivish" website, another story about Madoff's trustee to recoup money paid to investors.
Read the full article - Philanthropist Targeted in Madoff Complaint Plans to Fight Lawsuit - and let me know what you think.
Businessman and philanthropist Robert Lappin said he plans to fight a lawsuit filed against him by the trustee in the Bernard Madoff Ponzi scheme.So, why pick on Mr. Lappin, you ask? It seems that the earlier "investors," who in some ways were victimized by Madoff, received returns totaling more than they invested with Bernie. It seems to me that this was part of Bernie's plan--to pay excessive returns to the earlier folks that would act as a lure for others to join the scheme in hopes of reaping similar gains.
Bankruptcy trustee Irving Picard filed a complaint in federal court earlier this month seeking $1.8 million from the Shetland Fund Limited Partnership, which was headed by the 88-year-old Lappin.
Read the full article - Philanthropist Targeted in Madoff Complaint Plans to Fight Lawsuit - and let me know what you think.
Monday, December 27, 2010
Architecture to Entice India’s Top Engineers
From the New York Times
So, maybe basic human dignity and needs should be addressed before India's leading corporations begin sinking millions in "corporate sanctuaries."
Read the full report Architecture to Entice India’s Top Engineers
Well, that's what I think.
Stephen M. Flatow
In this nation where world-class high-tech companies co-exist with urban slums and rural poverty, employers like Tata, Infosys and Wipro have set out to create avant-garde, environmentally smart corporate sanctuaries.Whoa, who's kidding who? India's cities are one big slum where there are not enough toilets to go around for their residents, where fellow citizens are treated as human garbage by their betters, and, face it, life is cheap. Independent films coming out of India are accurate in their portrayal of urban poverty (the public bathroom scene in Slumdog Millionaire is not exaggeration) and human abuse (see Salaam Bombay.)
So, maybe basic human dignity and needs should be addressed before India's leading corporations begin sinking millions in "corporate sanctuaries."
Read the full report Architecture to Entice India’s Top Engineers
Well, that's what I think.
Stephen M. Flatow
Sunday, December 26, 2010
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)